A Guide to Dining in a Cape May

Cape May, New Jersey, renowned for its pristine beaches and Victorian charm, is equally celebrated for its vibrant culinary scene. Nestled along the Jersey Shore, this coastal paradise offers a diverse array of dining experiences that cater to all tastes and preferences. In this article, A Guide to Dining in a Cape May we’ll take you on a gastronomic journey through Cape May, highlighting its exceptional restaurants, fresh seafood, and the unique ambiance that makes dining here an unforgettable experience.

A Coastal Culinary Haven

Cape May’s dining scene is a reflection of its coastal location, with an emphasis on fresh seafood, locally sourced ingredients, and a commitment to culinary excellence. Whether you’re a seafood enthusiast or crave international flavors, there’s something for everyone in Cape May’s culinary landscape.

1. Fresh Seafood Delights

As a coastal town, Cape May is synonymous with fresh seafood. The Atlantic Ocean provides a bounty of delectable treasures, including succulent crab, plump shrimp, and flaky fish. Local restaurants take full advantage of this coastal wealth, serving up dishes like crab cakes, buttery lobster tails, and expertly grilled swordfish.

2. Farm-to-Table Fare

Cape May’s commitment to sustainability and local agriculture shines through its farm-to-table dining options. Restaurants collaborate with nearby farms and suppliers to offer dishes that celebrate the region’s seasonal produce. Be sure to explore menus featuring fresh Jersey tomatoes, locally grown greens, and artisanal cheeses.

3. Victorian Elegance

Dining in Cape May often carries an element of Victorian elegance. Many restaurants are housed in historic Victorian-era buildings, creating an ambiance that transports you to a bygone era. Dining in beautifully restored dining rooms or on charming outdoor patios adds a touch of romance to your culinary experience.

4. Al Fresco Dining

With its mild coastal climate, Cape May is perfect for al fresco dining. Many restaurants offer outdoor seating, allowing you to savor your meal while enjoying the fresh sea breeze and the picturesque views of the ocean or Cape May’s tree-lined streets.

5. International Flavors

While Cape May is celebrated for its seafood, it also offers a diverse range of international cuisines. From Italian trattorias and Mexican cantinas to Thai restaurants and French bistros, you can embark on a global culinary journey without leaving the town.

Notable Dining Establishments in Cape May

1. The Lobster House: A Cape May institution, The Lobster House offers fresh seafood in a casual yet bustling atmosphere. Enjoy your meal with a view of the fishing boats on the Cape May Harbor.
2. Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant: This upscale dining establishment in a Victorian mansion offers a sophisticated menu highlighting local ingredients. It’s an ideal spot for a romantic dinner.
3. The Mad Batter Restaurant & Bar: Known for its creative American cuisine, this restaurant offers a lively atmosphere and an extensive wine list. Don’t miss their famous brunch.
4. The Ebbitt Room: Located within the Virginia Hotel, this restaurant combines an elegant setting with a seasonal menu featuring farm-fresh ingredients.
5. Tisha’s Fine Dining: For a taste of international flavors, Tisha’s offers a diverse menu with options ranging from Mediterranean-inspired dishes to classic Italian fare.